On 17 November, the Department for Work and Pensions published Alan Milburn’s review of young people and work. From a Welfare State to a Working State focuses on the roughly one million young people in the UK who are ‘not in education, employment, or training’ (NEET). That is one in eight, and six in ten of them have never had a job.
Much of the coverage has centred on welfare reform, but the report has plenty to say to universities. It praises UK higher education as world-leading. Yet the review also heard from graduates who did everything asked of them and still could not secure a suitable first job. As Graduate Futures Institute (GFI) CEO Martin Edmondson put it, “Universities and their careers services are part of the essential infrastructure for tackling youth unemployment.”
Three shifts stand out for universities: graduate outcomes are becoming a core measure of performance, work experience needs to reach every student rather than the well connected, and support has to follow students from their studies into work.
The report says schools, colleges and universities must be judged by whether young people make successful transitions into further learning and work. It calls for higher education earnings data to be published prominently, so students can judge which courses and institutions deliver the strongest employment returns. GFI is also urging the Office for Students to increase the weighting on employability in the revised Teaching Excellence Framework.
For careers teams, that means needing timely insight.
Lack of experience is the biggest barrier the report identifies. It was cited by 53% of NEET young people who wanted to work, and by 57% of young people looking towards work in the Youth Voice Census, up from 47% a year earlier. Most young people felt able to write a CV, complete an application and attend an interview. Only 28% felt confident they had suitable experience, and just 31% felt they had the personal networks that might help them find an opening. Three in four said paid work experience would help.
The report also shows how unevenly experience is shared out. Many placements come through parents or family friends, leaving young people without those connections with fewer choices. Even when a placement happens, support afterwards is often slight, with little reflection on what was learned. Some young people said they were given easy, boring tasks that had little to do with the job.
The report wants experience of working life to become a normal part of education, starting with a statutory work experience duty on schools. Universities can lead the way by making opportunities visible to every student, actively brokering placements rather than leaving them to chance, and building in structured reflection so each placement becomes a genuine step towards work.
Symplicity CSM is designed to make experience happen at scale. Employer relationships sit in one place, so careers teams can source placements and internships well beyond any one student’s personal network. Every opportunity is visible to every student, not just those who know where to look. CSM also manages work-integrated learning from start to finish, including approvals, learning agreements, employer feedback and student reflection. That gives each placement a clear structure, and lets careers teams see which students have gained experience and which still need support to find their first opportunity.
Health and disability are at the heart of the report. Nearly half of NEET young people surveyed had a long-term health condition, compared with a quarter of their peers. Interestingly, the report finds that the prevalence of conditions like ADHD and autism has stayed largely flat, while diagnosis has risen. For universities, this means more students arriving with a diagnosis and an expectation that support will continue beyond the classroom, including into placements and first jobs. The report's recommendation is a hopeful one: young people should be able to get practical help as soon as a need becomes clear.
The report also shares the experiences of disabled young people on work placements. Some found that a placement didn’t have the access they needed. Others felt unsure about asking for adjustments, such as regular breaks. Alongside this, large employers are being encouraged to set ambitions for including more disabled young people in their workforce. Universities have a real opportunity here. When careers and disability teams work hand in hand, the support students rely on during their studies can carry through into placements and their first steps into work.
The report is blunt about data. Without a shared participation data infrastructure, it warns, cases cannot be joined up and nobody can know whether the system is working. It gives that data three jobs: identifying young people at risk, supporting one plan across services, and connecting the support provided to sustained outcomes.
Universities face the same challenge on a smaller scale. Careers, disability and wellbeing teams each hold part of a student’s story, but that information is often scattered across spreadsheets, inboxes and separate systems. The lesson from the report is that data has to be usable in-year, while a student can still be helped. Pulling it together once a year for a statutory return comes too late.
This is where the right platforms make a difference.
⭐ Symplicity CSM shows careers teams which students are engaging with appointments, events, jobs and placements, and which are not, so they can reach students early rather than discover the gap at graduation.
⭐ Symplicity Access gives disability teams a clear view of every support request, from first contact to adjustments in place, so they can see where students are waiting and act before support arrives too late.
The report proposes a new Youth Opportunity Service in every part of England by 2029, with careers education integrated into employment support. The proposed service covers England, but institutions in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland will face similar questions about graduate outcomes and experience. Universities bring the expertise and employer relationships that a more connected system will need. As GFI notes, “Better careers support must be matched by more opportunities for young people to put their skills into practice and make a successful start in working life.”
The Milburn Review asks institutions to do three things at once: evidence where students end up, widen access to meaningful experience, and make sure support reaches students when they need it. Symplicity is built to help universities do all three.
Symplicity CSM gives careers teams one place to manage the whole employability journey. Teams can build employer relationships, promote jobs and placements to every student, run events and appointments, and manage work-integrated learning from approval through to reflection. Throughout the year, CSM tracks engagement and outcomes, giving institutions the evidence they need as accountability for graduate destinations grows.
Symplicity Access helps disability and inclusion teams manage support requests, documentation and adjustments in one secure system. Students can request support online, teams can put adjustments in place quickly, and leaders can report on how well students are being supported.
The Milburn Review argues that a lost generation is a choice. Universities are well placed to help the country make a different one.